This weekend I posted about my hypothesis that the 3rd Planned Parenthood video deceptively shot and edited by the Center for Medical Progress did not contain video of a “fully formed fetus” (Carly Fiorina’s words), I believe it is a premature delivery. I reached that conclusion from 25 years of clinical practice in OB/GYN. I decided to ask nine other OB/GYNs what they thought about the clip, meaning I put a lot more effort into getting the facts than the politicians who voted to defund Planned Parenthood. All nine OB/GYNs agree with me. Several are OB/GYns who have done advanced training in family planning and so are experts in the field.

We all agree the video clip is highly unlikely to be from an abortion. We all agree it is likely a premature delivery. We all agree it can’t be from a Planned Parenthood clinic.

Here’s why:

  • The cord is clamped.  No one ever clamps the cord in a 2nd trimester abortion. Ever. No one has seen it and no one has even heard of it happening. If you want to see the image where I point out the clamp, click here. I know it disturbs some so I’m not reposting.
  • The condition of the skin. Fetal skin is very fragile at 18 weeks, but here it is perfect. There is also no bruising. With 2nd trimester abortions, even when the purpose is to deliver intact (which is rarely the case), there is some instrumentation and this always leaves marks. If this were an induction of labor there is almost always bruising and skin maceration. Inductions are only done for malformations and none are present.
  • The gestational age. Likely 18 weeks, maybe 20 weeks. At a Planned Parenthood an abortion at this gestation would be a D & E. Inductions don’t happen at Planned Parenthood.

The evidence suggests this is a premature delivery.  The perfect condition is typical of a rapid but atraumatic delivery, such as cervical incompetence or a second twin.

The video clip was provided by the Center for Bio-Ethical reform. This is what they had to say when questioned about the veracity:

“The video clip we provided to CMP depicted an intact delivery abortion. It was filmed at an abortion clinic. It was not a miscarriage. Mothers don’t go to abortion clinics to miscarry. Had this case been a miscarriage, the mother would have presented at a hospital and her baby would have been rushed to an isolette for appropriate neonatal care — not abandoned to writhe and eventually expire in a cold, stainless steel specimen vessel. As regards the organizational affiliation of the abortion facility in which this termination was performed, our access agreements forbid the disclosure of any information which might tend to identify the relevant clinics or personnel with whom we work. Preserving confidentiality is vital to future clinic access. I can, however, assure you that the footage in question is not anomalous. It is representative of the frequent outcomes of many late term intact delivery terminations performed at clinics of all organizational affiliations.”

So the people who deceptively edited videos and used without permission a picture of a stilbirth and passed it off as an abortion want us to take the word of an organization that cannot say when or where they obtained the video because they are getting videos under false pretenses?

When women deliver prematurely at a very early gestational age a stainless steel basin is often used as this what we have in the operating room and in delivery rooms. We use stainless steel not because we are mean or heartless, but because it can be sterilized for re-use (just like the clamp). Some operating rooms now use disposable plastic, but the video looks like it was converted from analog and so is likely old and steel was ubiquitous for many, many years.

If you want to get maximum shock value and you are not above lying you would use the best looking fetus you can find because you want people like Fiorina to scream about a “fully formed” perfect looking fetus on television. In fact, you dream about that.

And yes some anti-choice activists will say that they just needed a representative image, but if your plan is a “sting” video you actually have to show the supposedly illegal thing you are trying to catch people doing. You can’t say we need to close the beach for shark attacks because you are sure they are happening and then offer a woman with her leg bitten by a dog as proxy.

The purpose of the video clip is to convince people it is part of Holly O’Donnell’s completely unverifiable narrative. If there were true evidence of a crime, the claim of live births being harvested for brains, why not go straight to the authorities? If you are so concerned about “life” wouldn’t you drop everything and call 911?

Ten OB/GYNs who say the clip is likely a premature delivery and not representative of an abortion.




Join the Conversation


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

  1. Here’s more evidence that this was not an abortion: The words of Greg Cunningham (Center for Bio-Ethical Reform), the person who brought us this video, as cited in Time: “In an interview with TIME on Monday night, Cunningham said the fact that the fetus was not offered any medical treatment following the birth was evidence that the procedure was an abortion.” Meaning, it’s his “expert” medical opinion that it’s typical to intervene and try and save a 17-week premature birth or miscarriage (which we know from medical experts is not so) and that lack of such action is evidence of an abortion. But beyond that, he was not there, he did not see and did not get to interview the parties involved. In other words, we’re debating public policy based on bull—-.

    Source: “Questions Remain Over Whether Video Carly Fiorina Cited in Debate Shows Abortion” ti dot me/1M0uLtA

  2. I did some research about a year ago or so on how these activist get their hands on the abortion porn they use for propaganda. About 50% of it are photographs taken by Monica Migliorino Miller and some date back as far as the 80’s, before fetal tissue donation laws were in effect. They came from pathology labs and such as that for her to bury. The videos like this one are most likely from overseas, CBR has several international “partners” if you will that will allow them to film and photograph. This does not happen in the U.S. My guess is, this was filmed overseas where English is not the spoken language, that would explain why there is no audio for the general public to hear.

  3. If that photo was used without the parent’s knowledge or permission, isn’t that a HIPAA violation? Maybe the family wants to leave this in God’s hands, but I would think that the health care facility and whoever leaked it would be in big trouble.

  4. I am a pediatrician, and if a woman presented to a hospital with a fetus of that gestational age, it would not have been “rushed to an isolette for appropriate neonatal care”. The fetus pictured is clearly not viable, and there is therefore no neonatal care to be given, even if there is movement.

  5. Please keep on spreading the truth. You have the experience and perspective that we need to protect our reproductive rights.

  6. Actually, some women DO go to Planned Parenthood when they miscarriage because for some it’s their only source of healthcare. But the Centers for Medical Progress are still deceptive and clearly have an agenda.

    1. Centers for Medical progress are the same as Project Veritas run by James Okeffe who should be in jail for trying to wire a Senators office and recently had two girls trying to get in Hilliary’s camp. Thank you Jen for being about the only Dr. to speak up on this BS! Recently I went to my OB/GYN and was amazed at all the Birth-control that is available to women now a days! I don’t understand how abortion is really a “Thing” anymore, with plan B types of methods that I believe PP uses, but I’m glad the option is still available for young women.
      But these people… there have been Doctors TESTIFYING to Congress that Birth control, the “Pill” is abortion!!!
      What kind of Dr.s say such a thing? It is no question these people will say and do anything to take control away from women! Thank You Dr. Jenn for speaking up, and not being afraid! I wish you would go in front of Congress and tell them the truth. Women around the world thank YOU!

%d bloggers like this: